[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Are Green OA Self-Archiving Mandates Maoist Monstrosities?
- Subject: Re: Are Green OA Self-Archiving Mandates Maoist Monstrosities?
- From: Alma Swan <a.swan@TALK21.COM>
- Date: Thu, 17 Jan 2008 16:27:24 -0000
- Reply-to: email@example.com
- Sender: firstname.lastname@example.org
Jan Szczepanski commented on some remarks I made in a recent interview thus: > In the late fifties Mao Zedong introduced that Great Leap and > now fifty years later we are going to take a giant leap > according to Dr Swan. > > In China backyard steel furnances would do the job; in Dr Swans > world it's the mandate and local institutional repository that > is going to change the world away from big industry and the > capitalist society. > > Open Access is inevitable according to Dr Swan, as once > Socialism was. Mandate is the key to the Open Access World. > Instead of Five Year Plans we will have Metrics to see to it > that the way forward is the Green Way. > > The commissars overlooking that the Giant Leap will happen is > "Pro-Vice- Chancellors" at the universities, the real > reprsentatives of the research communities. I doubt I'm the only one to find the leap from OA mandates to Maoism somewhat challenging. According to Dr Szczepanski's mandate/Maoism link the new mandatory rule on NIH-funded research surely means that the US now has a communist Congress, something the Washington Post and New York Times surprisingly failed to recognise, thus missing the scoop of the millennium. Nevertheless, we can now look forward to the outing of all those closet communist rectors and provosts who introduce mandatory OA policies. Clearly OA is going to be much more effective than McCarthy ever was. > How will the future be? > > AS: Once the content and the infrastructure are in place we are > going to see knowledge take a giant leap. The way to view it is > that the last 7-8,000 years or so of human civilisation's > struggle for knowledge has taken place on one plane, determined > and constrained by what our own brains can absorb, put together > and make sense of: now we are about to move to another plane > altogether, with the help of machine brains. > >>From profit makers to machine brains, what a future! It is easier to make the leap from mandates to machine brains (semantic computer technologies), though, - the link is that mandates produce the open access content on which those machine tools can work - and those who are interested in this issue may like some of the resources that I found helpful when trying to get to grips with both the potential and the technologies of the semantic web: 1. A JISC Briefing Paper on text-mining written by the experts at the UK's National Centre for Text Mining: http://www.jisc.ac.uk/publications/publications/pub_textmining.aspx 2. For a nice, relatively recent overview of the semantic web, particularly helpful on the issue of ontologies and explaining clearly how they are applied in life science research: Shadbolt et al - "The Semantic Web Revisited". http://eprints.ecs.soton.ac.uk/12614/ 3. John Wilbanks on text mining the neuroscience literature. Try this: http://sciencecommons.org/projects/data/, but if you can, do go and listen to him in person. John spellbinds a conference hall with his energetic and jargon-free explanation of semantic tools at work on neuroscience content. 4. Peter Murray-Rust's group's work on mining the chemical literature, now well-developed: For example, see "Communication and re-use of chemical information in biosciences." http://www.dspace.cam.ac.uk/handle/1810/34579 5. Clark et al's interesting and forward-looking pedagogical perspective: Clark K, Parsia B and Hendler J: "Will the semantic web change education?". http://www-jime.open.ac.uk/2004/3/clark-2004-3-disc-paper.html To help things along, the Nature Publishing Group has developed OTMI, the Open Text-Mining Interface, which enables machines to get at the facts in a text-based research article (while preventing humans from reading it) for text-mining purposes. Alma Swan Key Perspectives Ltd Truro, UK P.S. The link to the original interview, for anyone who wants to read my ('Maoist') remarks in the context of the whole discussion, is: http://poynder.blogspot.com/2008/01/open-access-interviews-dr-alma-swan.html
- Prev by Date: Head of Continuing Resources, Revised application date
- Next by Date: Position Announcement - Welch Medical Library, Johns Hopkins U
- Previous by thread: Head of Continuing Resources, Revised application date
- Next by thread: Are Green OA Self-Archiving Mandates Maoist Monstrosities?