[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Leaving the Emerald City



I did a price history of the two economics journals published by Emerald, "Journal of Economic Studies" (2006 price $9,859), and the "International Journal of Social Economics" (2006 price $10,849). This history and some calculations can be found at: http://people.cornell.edu/pages/pmd8/emerald_economics.xls

The Journal of Economic Studies started at the University of Strathelyde's Dept. of Economics in Glasgow, Scotland in 1965 and remained at 7 British Pounds (about $15 USD) until 1981 when it began publishing with MCB (the former name of Emerald). Beginning in 1982 ($120), a series of double-digit annual price increases ensued until 2000 that averaged 28% per year. Several years saw amazing increases, such as from 88-89 when the journal price increased 71% (from $420 to $720), or from 95-96 when the journal went up by almost $1,000 (43%) in a single year ($2,730 to $3,700). The effects of double-digit compound interest took this journal to $6,838 in 2000. In 2001, MCB changed its name to Emerald, and part of their reaction to the outrage of the library community was price moderation. From 2001 to the present, we return to single-digit price increases, yet as we all know, 5% increase on an expensive journal can still result in a massive price increase. Over the last year, the price of this journal increased by only 5% (from $9,389 to $9,859) yet this reflected an increase of $470 (more than the price of most economics journals). Those interested in the pricing history of the International Journal of Social Economics can find this data from the above URL.

Returning to Joe Esposito's question about whether this increase reflects additional value to the consumer, or merely price gouging, I calculated the price per article over several years. In 1989, the Journal of Economic Studies published 23 articles in 6 issues at a price per article of $31. In 1995, they published 26 articles in 4 issues (there was a combined 3/4/5 issue), for a price of $88 per article. In 2005, they published 29 articles in 5 issues for a price of $324/article.

Compared to other journals in economics, the median price per article is about $13 (or $6 for non-profit publishers and $20 for for-profits) Furthermore, according to Bergstrom and McAfee's summary tables, Emerald leads the pack as the most expensive publisher with their median journal price being $7,409, and median price per article being $107 see: http://www.hss.caltech.edu/~mcafee/Journal/Summary.pdf While these two economics journals published by Emerald are clearly exceptional compared to other journals in economics, they are not exceptional for Emerald.

Lastly, Joe asked what the subscriber base is for these journals. A search on OCLC Worldcat turns up 161 print library holdings, yet most of the libraries that provide holdings information cancelled during the late 1980s through the early 1990s. Rumors on the street are that the number of subscribing libraries to be less then 10. If the theory of price elasticity is true for library subscriptions, a publisher can make much more money selling fewer subscriptions at a higher price. If you don't care about maximizing readership or building prestige, this is clearly the way to go. But if you don't believe me, just read, "What Self-Made Millionaires Really Think, Know and Do : A Straight-Talking Guide to Business Success and Personal Riches", by former MCB/Emerald owners Richard Dobbins and Barry O. Pettman. "Together they founded a publishing company with no capital and recently became multimillionaires when the business was sold."


--Phil Davis