[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Annee Phil. followup.
- To: email@example.com
- Subject: Annee Phil. followup.
- From: "James J. O'Donnell" <firstname.lastname@example.org>
- Date: Thu, 1 Aug 2002 11:42:08 EDT
- Reply-To: email@example.com
- Sender: firstname.lastname@example.org
Thank you all, first of all, who wrote with very helpful messages when I asked a couple of weeks ago for concrete cases of institutions and classes being disenfranchised from L'Annee Philologique by the publisher's insistence on French legal jurisdiction. Let me ask that if anyone has not written to me (email@example.com), I'd still be glad to hear from you: that is, if you represent or know of substantial groups of users who would be unable to get access to L'Annee Phil. if the jurisdiction clause is insisted upon. There have been a variety of ideas presented by some of my correspondents in this process for getting around the impasse. I list some without prejudice and would be happy to hear comments (especially comments on any that are still showstoppers): 1. Sign it and cross your fingers. (I think that works only if you have some legal possibility of signing it, not the case for most state universities.) 2. Remove the clause entirely and fight it out *only* if a case arises (the chances of which are fiercely unlikely). 3. Write it so that in case of legal action, the jurisdiction is that of the defendant (this to discourage excessive litigiousness). 4. Persuade the publisher to outsource delivery to one of the big aggregators of e-databases that already has a more robust business and technical system in place and that is able to be more flexible on the jurisdiction matter. I do not know at this point what tack the American Philological Association will take in approaching the publisher, and we have some back channels through which to have arms' length conversation beforehand in the hope of getting a good resolution this fall. Jim O'Donnell Georgetown University
- Prev by Date: Cataloging 'free' web materials
- Next by Date: The Catalog vs. The Homepage: Best Practices in Providing Access to Electronic Resources
- Prev by thread: The Catalog vs. The Homepage: Best Practices in Providing Access to Electronic Resources
- Next by thread: Cataloging 'free' web materials